what i dont understand is why dont you ask stakeholders fiirst and let them chose if they want a asset or xem? so everyone gets what he wants and is happy...
if your answer is that most would chose xem - so you have your answer. if most decide for silverasset is ok too. everybody gets what he wants....
Nothing is free. The silver coins will be paid for by the real stakeholders through the devaluation of their stakes. The best way to do it would be to distribute those sock XEM to all stakeholders raising the initial stake amount and allow them to buy a silver asset on the exchange voluntarily. Like mix has already said, here or on telegram, it's not really a silver backed asset unless it can be exchanged on demand for said asset.
You are asking fellow NEMsters to accept a lot, and to go along with it, with little to no real details.
I think establishing a real world tradeable asset on the NEM exchange is an excellent idea and I fully support it. The process is the only thing I am unsure or confident in.
We are all very supportive and want NEM to be the best it can be, and also very protective of it.
If someone would put forth a solid business plan around this and let everyone vett it, I think it would alleviate the fears and we can move on.